RSMC Services

The Working Interview: How to Try a Dental Hire Out Before You Commit 

The Working Interview: How to Try a Dental Hire Out Before You Commit 

I like working interviews because they show what a regular interview can’t: how someone handles the real rhythm of a dental practice. But a try-out only helps when it’s structured, respectful, and handled as paid work when the candidate performs productive tasks. 

A few focused hours can reveal more than another round of polished answers. They can also help the candidate decide whether your team, pace, and practice feel right for them. That’s the point: a mutual try-out, not an audition. 

Start with the pay question 

If a candidate does productive work, plan to pay them for their time. Setting up an operatory, supporting a real patient, answering calls, and completing practice tasks can all raise wage-and-hour questions. Federal law considers work an employer “suffers or permits” to happen compensable, and state rules may add requirements. Check the details with your payroll or employment advisor before scheduling the day. The U.S. Department of Labor’s FLSA guidance offers a useful starting point. 

Agree in writing on the role, date, hours, pay rate, and payment process. Don’t make payment dependent on whether you hire the candidate. Confirm payroll treatment, workers’ compensation, insurance, and any state-specific requirements with the right advisor. 

Keep the line clear: A conversation or office tour isn’t the same as productive work. When in doubt, ask your employment advisor how to structure and pay the try-out. 

Clinical duties need extra care. Confirm the candidate’s license, permits, and scope of practice for your state before any patient care. Rules differ. For example, the Dental Board of California explains permitted dental auxiliary duties, while the Mississippi State Board of Dental Examiners says dentists and hygienists need a current Mississippi license to treat patients during a working interview.

Pick a format that fits the role 

Working interviews tend to suit dental assistants, front-desk coordinators, and hygienists, provided you follow supervision and licensing rules. Choose tasks that let you observe job-related skills without asking someone to work beyond their credentials. 

For associate dentists, a paid shadow day or short locum-style trial may fit better. For an office manager, consider a half-day of observation followed by a realistic planning exercise. A candidate might review a fictional schedule and explain how they’d respond to a late cancellation, for example. 

For every role, keep the try-out short. Two to four hours gives you time to observe a few meaningful tasks without turning the day into a full shift. 

Two women discussing at a reception desk, with a computer and plant between them.

Give the day a simple shape 

A clear plan makes the visit more useful for everyone. Choose a host who knows the work and can guide the candidate, but isn’t the person the new hire would replace. Tell the team in advance, explain what you want to learn, and ask them to share specific observations. 

Here’s a sample three-hour schedule: 

Table outlining a three-hour schedule with time intervals and activities, including introductions, role expectations, observation tasks, candidate questions, and next steps.

Be thoughtful about patient privacy. Use mock records, training software, or a mannequin when they’ll help you evaluate skills without exposing confidential information or involving a candidate in tasks they aren’t authorized to perform. 

Decide what you’ll watch for 

Write down four to six observable behaviors before the visit. Don’t score someone on “vibe.” A friendly first impression matters, but it shouldn’t outweigh the behaviors the job actually requires. 

Table listing possible observations for dental assistants, front desk staff, and hygienists.

For each item, use a simple rating (such as “meets,” “needs coaching,” or “not observed”) and add one short note of evidence. “Asked a clarifying question before changing the appointment” tells you more than “seemed confident.” 

Two dental professionals examining a dental chart and model in a modern clinic.

A small scorecard you can reuse 

Table row showing the behavior “Prepares the space and tools thoughtfully,” with columns for Rating and Evidence.
Behavior evaluation table with columns for behavior, rating, and evidence, listing communication, workflow adherence, attention to detail, and response to feedback.

Use role-specific items in the same format. If you didn’t have a chance to observe something, mark “not observed” instead of guessing. 

Protect the team and the candidate 

A team that feels ambushed by a stranger in their operatory won’t give you useful feedback. Tell staff who’s coming, why you’re using a working interview, and what you want them to notice. Ask the host to make introductions and explain the day’s boundaries. 

Also pay attention to how the candidate treats the team when they think it doesn’t count. Respect, listening, and basic courtesy are part of the job. 

If the candidate currently works elsewhere, schedule discreetly. Don’t contact their current employer or share their job search without permission. Be honest about whether the visit includes real work, what they’ll be asked to do, how long it will last, and how it will be paid. The Dental Assisting National Board’s guide also reminds candidates that a working interview gives them a chance to assess the practice. 

If it’s clearly not a fit, end kindly 

Sometimes you’ll know before the scheduled time ends. Don’t keep someone there just to fill the calendar. Thank them, explain that you’ve seen enough for today, and close the visit respectfully. Pay them for the time worked and follow the arrangement you documented. 

Then follow up promptly, ideally within a day or two. If you’re not moving forward, say so clearly and thank them for their time. If the try-out went well, move quickly with a specific next step. Strong candidates may be considering other opportunities, too. 

When the try-out and interview don’t match 

A great conversation followed by a mediocre try-out deserves a closer look. Ask whether the candidate had enough orientation, whether nerves or unclear instructions got in the way, and whether you observed the skills that matter. Don’t dismiss a mismatch, but don’t ignore it either.

The try-out gives you evidence of how someone approached real tasks in your practice that day. The interview gives you context about their experience, judgment, and goals. Compare both against your written criteria, then ask the candidate about anything that surprised you. 

Common mistakes to avoid 

• Asking for productive work without planning to pay for it. 

• Starting with no defined tasks or evaluation criteria. 

• Having the person being replaced act as the only host. 

• Letting a short visit quietly turn into an eight-hour shift. 

• Scoring on personality or “fit” without noting job-related evidence. 

• Skipping the debrief because the schedule ran long. 

Expert tip: Put the debrief on the calendar before the candidate arrives. Even ten focused minutes can prevent scattered impressions from becoming the hiring decision. 

Healthcare professionals and patients discussing care around a table in a bright office

Key takeaways 

• Treat the working interview as a two-way try-out, not a free shift. 

• Confirm pay, payroll, scope, supervision, and insurance details before the visit. • Keep the session focused, usually two to four hours, with a named host. 

• Observe a few job-related behaviors and record specific evidence. 

• Protect the current team, candidate privacy, patient privacy, and candidate dignity. • Debrief quickly and communicate the next step without leaving the candidate guessing. 

A good working interview won’t guarantee a perfect hire. It can help you make a more informed choice and give the candidate a clearer picture of the team they may join.

If you’re hiring and want help finding the right dental professional, reach out to RSMC Services. We can talk through recruitment and temp-to-perm support, so you can spend less time sorting applications and more time choosing the right fit. Call +1 650-447-1527 or email careers@rsmcser vices.com. You can also explore who we serve.

Build Your Team with Confidence

Whether you’re staffing one clinic or an entire network, RSMC delivers the 

expertise, efficiency, and personalized service your organization deserves.

Let's Solve Your Hiring Problem

Book a no-obligation consultation with our team. We’ll show you how to streamline your recruitment and build a team that lasts.

    🙏🏿 Thank you for your interest in serving with the R.S.M.C. Foundation. Please complete this inquiry form and our team will follow up with next steps.

















    [radio* fundraising-help use_label_element "Yes, please!" "No, thank you."]